How to increase prices in your online store without losing customers
Miguel Nicolás
-
We’ll share some strategies to adjust your prices, maintain customer trust, and stay competitive.
-
-
You know better than anyone that costs have been rising for months, but you are reluctant to pass them on to customers for fear of losing them. I understand, it is difficult.But in this article, we will help you. How? By explaining how to decide which products to adjust, when to give notice and what to tell your customers so that most do not consider leaving.Because data is there: in September, the CPI closed at 4.9 % year on year, six tenths of a percentage point higher than in August, according to the INE. The increase also affects one of the greatest concerns for an eCommerce business: Correos increased its parcel delivery rates by an average of 3 % for 2026. Add to this what your supplier charges, advertising and the payment gateway, and each order most likely leaves you with less money today than a year ago.Despite all this, many stores still hesitate to adjust prices because they believe they could lose many customers along the way. This fear has some basis, since, according to a Capterra study, price increases were the main reason Spanish consumers stopped buying a particular brand in 2022.However, not all price increases are the same. There is a considerable difference between an increase that customers discover unexpectedly in their basket and one that has been prepared strategically. Let us examine the latter.
-
How do you know it is time to increase prices?
-
Before changing anything, calculate the current margin on your 10 bestselling products. By current, we mean including everything: product cost, packaging, shipping (if you cover it), payment gateway fees and the proportional share of advertising (SEM, Social Media…).Now, perform the same calculation using the data from a year ago and compare the results you obtain.If you are hesitant or reluctant to do so, review these signs because they are revealing indicators:
- Your suppliers have increased their prices this year and you have left yours unchanged.
- You are selling more than last year, but at the end of the month you are left with the same amount (or even less).
- You offer free shipping above a threshold you calculated using 2024 shipping rates.
- You have not reviewed prices for over a year and your competitors have updated theirs. Always monitor prices.
Just one of these signs makes it worth reviewing the figures. With two or more… every passing month you are losing money and competitiveness in the market. -
Do you increase prices across the entire catalogue or select specific products?
-
The fact is that it is usually unnecessary to update the entire catalogue. Remember that your store has products whose prices customers know by heart or compare before buying, and others whose prices they barely notice. The former should be adjusted as little as possible, but the latter give you greater room for manoeuvre.Let us consider an example. Imagine an online speciality coffee store. Its flagship product is a 250 g bag of a particular variety that many people compare with those of other roasters, making it easy for regular customers to notice the difference. However, there are accessories that are almost always purchased alongside the coffee (the familiar cross-selling and bundle packs).A reasonable, and carefully considered, price increase might look like this:ProductCurrent priceNew priceIncreaseSpeciality coffee 250 g9.90 €9.90 €0 %Manual grinder39.90 €43.90 €10 %Paper filters (100 units)5.90 €6.50 €10 %Free shipping on orders over40,00 €45,00 €12.5 %The coffee, which attracts customers and is compared most often, remains unchanged. We apply the increase to products that raise the order value and to the free shipping threshold.That last change is one of the least noticeable: customers already spending 45 € pay nothing more, while those spending 41 € have a reason to complete their order, for example, with a bag of filters.There are other levers you can combine with the increase, or use as alternatives if you prefer. Three useful measures come to mind:
- Reduce fixed discounts. If you offer a 15 % welcome voucher, reducing it to 10 % does not change any catalogue price.
- Create bundles. A coffee and filter bundle at a fixed price increases the average order value without customers comparing each product individually.
- Adjust shipping charges for small orders, which are usually where the most money is lost.
What I do recommend avoiding wherever possible, is reducing quantity while maintaining the price, the familiar “shrinkflation”. Moving from 250 to 220 g without mentioning it may seem less conspicuous to most people, but loyal customers eventually notice and perceive it as deception, a form of dishonesty considerably worse than transparently asking for 60 cents more. -
-
Should you notify your customers? How far in advance?
-
There are many different situations here. It will always depend on who the customer is, how much they spend and how frequently they purchase. Visitors arriving from Google for the first time require no explanation: they see the new price and that is all. A mass communication, such as a homepage banner announcing price increases, only draws attention to something they would not have noticed and creates a negative predisposition.Customers who have purchased from you before are a different matter. They do remember what they paid, and discovering the change in their carts feels much worse than reading it in a clear and transparent email from you.Aim to give at least 2 or 3 weeks' notice to customers who meet any of these criteria:
- They have purchased any of the products whose prices you will increase in the last 6 months.
- They have a subscription or a recurring order. In this case, first review what your terms and conditions say about price changes, to avoid a legal problem.
- They purchase from you as a business and work with fixed budgets.
The notice has a side effect that can work in your favour: if you provide a deadline for purchasing at the current price, many customers bring their orders forward. Use it honestly, it is not an ethical strategy if it is untrue. The date you specify must be the current date.A seasonal note: If you are reading this close to November, bear in mind the Black Friday campaign.When you announce a discount, the previous price you display, must be the lowest you have applied in the previous 30 days. If you increase a product's price in early November and discount it at the end of the month, the reference remains the old price and the discount you can advertise is reduced.For products you intend to include in promotions, you should increase prices earlier or wait until January. -
What should you say when increasing prices (and what should you avoid)?
-
This is a delicate matter, which is why many online stores handle it poorly. Sometimes the message is overly dramatic, with three paragraphs of apologies, and at other times they say too little, with excessively vague wording, something like: "prices are being updated" without explaining anything at all.Communication matters: according to Qualtrics, communication problems are among the leading causes of poor customer experiences.If in doubt, follow this simple rule: state what is changing, by how much, from when and why, with specific figures and without apologising.Some examples:Instead of thisWrite this"We regret to inform you that, due to the difficult economic situation, we are obliged to…""From 15 November some prices will change. We explain which ones and why.""Our prices are increasing by 10 %.""The grinder is changing from 39.90 € to 43.90 €. The coffee remains unchanged.""Everything has become more expensive and we cannot cope any longer.""Our supplier has increased its rates twice this year. We absorbed the first increase; we can no longer absorb the second.""We remain committed to the highest quality.""We continue to roast every Monday and dispatch your order within 24 hours."Notice that the versions on the right provide information customers can verify. This makes them credible. Stating which products do not change also helps, because it turns general news into something clearly defined.And sign with a person's name. An email signed "Laura, from [store]" is better received than one from "The team". It is much easier to empathise with someone like you and me, than with a brand.
-
What email should you send? Three templates you can adapt
-
Replace the text in square brackets and adapt the tone to your brand. The more specific the reason you provide, the better it will work.
-
#1 - Notice to regular customers
-
Subject: Some prices change on [date] (and how to purchase beforehand)Hello, [name]:We are writing because you have purchased from us before and we want you to hear this directly from us.From [date] these prices will change:
- [Product]: from [X] € to [Y] €
- [Product]: from [X] € to [Y] €
The rest of the catalogue remains unchanged, including [your bestselling product].The reason: [a specific sentence, for example "our ceramics workshop has increased its rates by 12 % this year"]. We have held off for as long as possible before passing this on.If anything on the list interests you, it is available at the usual price until [date].Thank you for staying with us, [Name], from [store] -
#2 - Notice to subscribers with a frozen price
-
Subject: Your subscription retains its price until [date]Hello, [name]:From [date], the [product] subscription will change from [X] € to [Y] € per month for new customers.To reward your loyalty, we would like to inform you that you will continue paying [X] € until [date, for example, three months later]. From that date you will pay [Y] €.If this does not suit you, you can pause or cancel your subscription at any time, through [link], without calls or forms.Kind regards, [Name], from [store]
-
#3 - Reply to a customer complaint
-
Hello, [name]:You are right: [product] has changed from [X] € to [Y] €. Thank you for writing to us rather than simply leaving.Let me explain the reason: [specific reason]. We have tried to ensure the increase affects as few products as possible, and [alternative product] retains its price.As you have been purchasing from us since [year], here is a code for your next order: [CODE], offering a [5] % discount until [date].Kind regards, [Name]In the third case, the promotional code is optional. Use it with customers who truly matter to you, rather than as an automatic response to every complaint, or you will end up encouraging dissatisfaction.
-
What if a customer leaves?
-
It is inevitable, some customers will leave, and it is advisable to review the figures beforehand to avoid becoming alarmed and reversing course prematurely (a serious mistake, incidentally).Imagine a product you sell for 20 € excluding VAT that provides an 8 € margin. If you increase its price by 2 €, the margin rises to 10 €. With 100 sales a month you earned 800 €; at the new price you only need to sell 80 to earn the same amount. In other words, you could lose 20 % of that product's sales and remain in the same position.In practice, the decline is usually considerably smaller when the increase is communicated effectively. To check this in your case, monitor the following over the next four weeks:
- The conversion rate of product pages with increased prices, compared with the same weeks of the previous year, thereby avoiding confusion between the increase and seasonality.
- The average order value, particularly if you have adjusted the free shipping threshold.
- Repeat purchases by your regular customers: whether those who purchased every month continue to do so.
- Subscription cancellations, if applicable.
- Customer service messages that mention price.
If a particular product's sales collapse and create a serious problem, you can always reverse the increase, but only for that product.In general remember that it is always easier to correct a small increase than to recover a year's lost margin. -
How much is not increasing prices costing you?
-
It is striking to view it this way, but remember that every month you maintain a price that no longer covers your costs, you are subsidising out of your own pocket part of your customers' orders. Many of them are not even aware of it, and most would understand a reasonable increase explained clearly.So this week calculate the current margin on your ten bestselling products. With those figures in front of you, deciding which prices to increase becomes much easier.
-
Do you already know how to increase prices in your online store without losing customers or profitability, or do you still have any questions?



